(to u laila)

[otb_sami]

Thanks indeed Laila
If u have shorten the clause wether with which or without which , u should take out the the relative noun and the verb be
remember he said shorten the clause not the sentence
but if he said take out the clause even he said as possible u have to take all the clause out

A NOTE: HE SAID AS POSSIBLE MAYBE TO CONFUSE THE .
.CONFIDENT PUPILS

I appreciate ur participation Laila

[oimas]

مشكور اخوي otb_sami
بالضبط زي ماقلت وشكرا على مشاركاتك الجميله واللي في نفس الوقت تكون between the lines

[oO Laila Oo]

Thanks dear

I appreciate ur efforts in explaining this rule


May u kindly answer the questions in the last topic

If u have no time ,,, never mind


thanks again